material Contravention of CDP voted by County Council

According to a piece in the Irish Times, "COUNCILLORS IN Co Louth have voted to materially contravene the county development plan to grant permission for a supermarket on a greenfield site on the outskirts of Ardee near a link road with the M1 motorway." Curiously the councillors decided to go ahead with this despite the fact that the impact on Ardee traders has not been assesssed, there is no public transport option (the fact that people already walk along the hard shoulder of the link road is an accident waiting to happen); the Eastern Regional Fisheries Board pointed out that the impact on the local river was inadequate and that the treatment centre must be upgraded (not much chance of that in the next few years!) Dearey (GP) and Nash (Lab) were the only councillors to oppose the proposal. In an extraordianry assertion, Jim Lennon (FG), the proposer, stated that it was just what Ardee needed!!! (or was it just what Jim needed?)

The troubled Quinn Group is once again under fire over the controversial gas fired power plant at Toomes near Louth Village following an major explosion at a similar plant in upstate New York which, according to the Argus, "was the scene of a massive explosion last Sunday which left 50 feared dead". In the event hundreds were injured but thankfully there were only five fatalities. According to an item in NewsTime, "There are so many unanswered questions: What led to this disaster? What were the contributing factors? Could anything have been done to prevent it?" (State Governor) Rell said. "These are the questions that we must answer now, not only for the sake of the victims and their families but to avoid tragedies like this in the future."

These same questions equally apply to the Toomes plant, which may be at even greater risk due to the enclosed hollow where it is located. Furthermore there are human dwellings and a national school within a few hundred metres of this plant. Given the farcical testimony from the Fire Chief at the oral hearing, who was unable to explain how he would deal with a fire on the site if an explosion damaged the 5000 litre fire water storage tank, and the complacent attitude of the HSA representative, all approvals for this plant should be suspended pending a safety review.

It is interesting to note that the Quinn Group indicated during the oral hearing that it had no plans for further developments in the area, and indeed the conditions imposed by ABP would appear to reflect the boards concerns in this area. No mention was made of a second plant, in this case an Open Cycle Gas Turbine plant mentioned by Mott McDonald on their web site:

"2007 MMP completed the feasibility studies, technical studies, Eirgrid application, the Environmental Impact assessment, tender documents and planning application for the Phase 1 450MW CCGT at Toomes in Louth. The Client was Quinn Energy.

2007 MMP completed the feasibility studies, technical studies, Eirgrid application, the Environmental Impact assessment and will soon submit the planning application for a 180MW OCGT also at Toomes in Louth. The Client is confidential."

Could it be that the second client is also Quinn, contrary to what was suggested at the oral hearing. In many other matters, notably its dealings with Anglo Irish Bank, Quinn has continued to refuse to fully disclose its exposure according to newspaper reports, to the extent that "Mr Tolan (CEO VHI) called for the full extent of Mr Quinn’s losses on Anglo to be disclosed, saying that they “should be in the public domain” as they were “relevant for people who buy their products”.

Planning Matters

We have had a number of significant planning decisions in recent months. The first was the decision by the Dundalk to refuse permission for several houses at Soldier's Point - reference 0910. This site has had an extended history and the council documents in its regard make instructive reading, especially the Planner's Report. The environmental study, carried out by a Fiona Doris (apparently a botonist) seems to have been particularly deficient.














Extract from planners report

The applicant has now appealed the councils decision to An Bord Planeala...

Another application that the council refused is of similar interest. In this case the proposal was to build a house on what remains of Ardee Bog, a pNHA (proposed Natural Heritage Area). The application, 09756, was refused for this reason, and also because it is in a flood plane, and is at odds with CDP zoning. It is interesting to reflect how times have changed - the council allowed a major infilling operation several years ago to facilitate a football pitch!



















The infilled football pitch is in the centre of the brown bog area.

While these decisions may be bad news for the developers concerned, they are good news for Louth's long-suffering environment!